Spector Gadon Rosen Vinci P.C. Members Brooke C. Madonna and David B. Picker have successfully secured affirmance of the Summary Judgment entered in favor of their clients, Andrea Desy Edrei, Michael Skokowski and Kailey Bondiskey, in the Philadelphia Common Pleas case of TCS Black Label Realty, LLC and The Condo Shop, LLC v. Ryan Serhant, Serhant Pennsylvania, LLC, Andrea Desy Edrei, Michael Skokowski, Jr. and Kailey Bondiskey. 2026 WL 251144, 2026 PA Super 17 (Pa.Super., Jan. 30, 2026).

Appellants appealed from the summary judgment entered against them on all counts by Judge Patrick on November 5, 2024. After hearing argument on August 13, 2025, the Pennsylvania Superior Court, on January 30, 2026, affirmed summary judgment on all seven claims, holding Appellants failed to produce fact-grounded proof of damages and relied on a speculative expert report that assumed destruction of Black Label’s profits, despite contrary testimony by Plaintiffs’ principals that Black Label remained in business. The court also affirmed rejection of Plaintiffs’ misappropriation, tortious interference, conversion, breach of fiduciary duty, and breach of contract claims, finding insufficient evidence of a breach and/or insufficient evidence linking any breach to any actual damages.

The case, ongoing for a number of years, was previously publicized by Law 360.

Brooke C. Madonna has been with Spector Gadon Rosen Vinci P.C. since 1992. As Of Counsel at the firm, Ms. Madonna has gained experience in trial and appellate work in both state and federal courts in Pennsylvania, New Jersey and Florida. Ms. Madonna practices commercial litigation with a primary focus in employment law including sexual harassment, Family Medical Leave Act, Americans with Disabilities Act and all forms of discrimination. Ms. Madonna also regularly represents individuals and businesses in cases involving real estate, construction, fraud, collection and casualty defense.

Combining careful analysis with clarity and forcefulness of expression, while never losing sight of clients’ practical needs, now-retired David B. Picker has broad experience representing plaintiffs and defendants in both trial and appellate courts in a wide range of commercial litigation matters, including contracts, commercial fraud, creditors’ rights, bankruptcy, professional malpractice, real estate, letter of credit, copyright, trademark, unfair competition, and trust and estate matters.

Spector Gadon Rosen Vinci P.C. has represented clients nationally and internationally for over 50 years and provides counsel and expertise across the entire spectrum of legal practice, from complex litigation to sophisticated transactional and corporate matters. The firm has offices in Philadelphia, New Jersey, Florida, and New York.